Family Autonomy and Class Fate (pages 131-149)

Gideon Calder

ABSTRACT: The family poses problems for liberal understandings of social justice, because of the ways in which it bestows unearned privileges. This is particularly stark when we consider inter-generational inequality, or ‘class fate’ – the ways in which inequality is transmitted from one generation to the next, with the family unit ostensibly a key conduit. There is a recognized tension between the assumption that families should as far as possible be autonomous spheres of decision-making, and the assumption that we should as far as possible equalize the life chances of all children, regardless of background. In this article I address this tension by way of recent liberal egalitarian literature, and consideration of the different dimensions of class fate. I argue, firstly, that the tension may not be of the a priori nature which liberals have tended to identify – and secondly, that as well as distributive and recognition-based aspects, the notion of contributive justice provides a particularly illuminating way of analyzing what is wrong about class fate, and the role of the family in promoting it.

application-pdf Download PDF

About Gideon Calder

Check Also

Reparations for Recent Historical Injustices. The Case of Romanian Communism (pages 151-162)

Horaţiu Traian Crişan ABSTRACT: The debate concerning the legitimacy of awarding reparations for historical injustices …